← Back to Blog

Detecting Malicious MCP Servers: A Practical Guide with MCP Shark

Learn how to identify suspicious MCP server behavior, audit tool lists, and monitor requests and responses for security threats using MCP Shark's forensic analysis capabilities.

Why MCP Server Security Matters

MCP servers have significant access to your development environment. They can execute tools, read resources, and process prompts that may contain sensitive information. A malicious MCP server could:

  • Exfiltrate sensitive code or credentials
  • Execute unauthorized commands on your system
  • Modify files or configurations without your knowledge
  • Access private resources or APIs
  • Inject malicious code into your development workflow

MCP Shark acts as a security observability layer, allowing you to monitor and audit all MCP server interactions before they can cause harm.

What Makes an MCP Server Suspicious?

1. Unusual Tool Lists

When an MCP server registers its tools, inspect the tool list carefully. Red flags include:

  • Tools with overly broad permissions (e.g., "execute_any_command", "read_all_files")
  • Tools that don't match the server's stated purpose
  • Unexpected tools appearing after updates
  • Tools with vague or misleading names

Use MCP Shark's MCP Playground to view all available tools from all servers. You can also capture the tools/list response in the Traffic Capture view and review all available tools.

2. Suspicious Tool Calls

Monitor tool calls for:

  • Tools accessing files outside their expected scope
  • Network requests to unknown or suspicious domains
  • Commands that modify system configurations
  • Excessive data exfiltration (large response payloads)
  • Tools called without explicit user action

MCP Shark's Traffic Capture shows you exactly which tools are being called, with what parameters, and what they return. You can filter by method tools/call to see all tool invocations.

3. Unusual Resource Access

Watch for:

  • Resources that expose sensitive information
  • Unexpected resource URIs or patterns
  • Resources that change content unexpectedly
  • Access to resources outside the server's domain

Using MCP Shark for Security Auditing

Step 1: Baseline Normal Behavior

Before using a new MCP server, use MCP Shark to establish a baseline:

  1. Start MCP Shark and configure it with your IDE
  2. Use the MCP Playground to explore available tools, prompts, and resources
  3. Review the initial tools/list response in Traffic Capture
  4. Document expected tools and their purposes
  5. Test each tool in the Playground to understand behavior

Step 2: Monitor Tool Calls

In MCP Shark's Traffic Capture view, filter by method tools/call to see all tool invocations. For each call, inspect:

  • Tool name: Does it match what you expected?
  • Parameters: Are the arguments reasonable and within scope?
  • Response: Does the response contain unexpected data?
  • Timing: Are tools being called without your explicit action?

Step 3: Audit Resource Access

Filter by resources/read to see all resource access. Verify:

  • Resources are only accessed when needed
  • Resource URIs match expected patterns
  • No sensitive files or data are being read
  • Resource content hasn't been tampered with

Step 4: Export and Analyze

Export captured traffic in JSON format for deeper analysis:

  1. Apply filters to isolate suspicious activity
  2. Click Export and choose JSON format
  3. Analyze the exported data to search for patterns across multiple sessions
  4. Identify tools that are called frequently or unexpectedly
  5. Detect data exfiltration by analyzing response sizes
  6. Create reports for security reviews

Red Flags to Watch For

🚨 Immediate Concerns

  • Tools that execute shell commands or system calls
  • Network requests to external domains you don't recognize
  • Large data transfers in responses
  • Tools that modify files outside their stated scope
  • Unexpected tool calls during idle periods

⚠️ Warning Signs

  • Tools with permissions broader than necessary
  • Frequent updates that change tool behavior
  • Vague or misleading tool descriptions
  • Resources that expose more data than expected
  • Unusual error patterns or retry behavior

Best Practices for MCP Security

  • Always use MCP Shark: Never connect directly to untrusted MCP servers without monitoring
  • Review before use: Inspect tool lists and test in isolation before production use
  • Regular audits: Periodically review captured traffic for anomalies
  • Limit permissions: Configure MCP servers with minimal necessary permissions
  • Keep logs: Export and archive traffic logs for security audits
  • Update carefully: Review changes when updating MCP servers
  • Use the playground: Test suspicious tools in MCP Shark's playground before production use

Real-World Example

Imagine you install a new MCP server that claims to help with code formatting. Using MCP Shark, you discover:

  1. The server registers a tool called "format_code" (expected)
  2. But it also registers "read_file" and "network_request" (unexpected)
  3. When you format code, MCP Shark shows the server also calls "read_file" on unrelated files
  4. The server makes network requests to an unknown domain

Without MCP Shark, you might never notice these suspicious activities. With it, you can immediately identify and block the malicious behavior.

Next Steps

Continue learning about MCP security:

Start monitoring your MCP servers today

Download MCP Shark and begin auditing your MCP server security.